The road Godhamnlivegen was earlier in CS, but not the full length of it. I joined the segments in OSM to one road. However, now it is missing after syncing the map with CS.
The difference I see from other roads is that it is on “layer 1”, not sure if this matters
Way: Godhamnlivegen (258359946) | OpenStreetMap is excluded due to the toll=yes tagging
Thanks James for clarifying!
I suspect this will be a fixed limitation for CS, but I need to ask anyway.
This road and others in my muncipality that are toll roads are free to walk/run. I don`t want to change OSM to toll=no as that would be incorrect.
Is there some other tag I could add to OSM to would add the road to CS?
According to Key:toll - OpenStreetMap Wiki you can use toll:foot=no, so I guess @JamesChevalier could add this to the query?
Good idea Hans, Hopefully that will let me add the missing roads 
How about toll:motor_vehicle=yes instead of toll=yes?
Scratch that, that probably has other side effects. The toll:foot=no option is probably the best one.
I’m concerned about switching from toll != yes to toll:foot != no because it might require updating OSM for many toll roads.
There are 2,101 Way records in Norway tagged toll=yes and 2 that are also tagged toll:foot=no - Way: Hummelvikveien (1198735639) | OpenStreetMap and Way: Vind-Birkelandsveien (693052133) | OpenStreetMap
I’ll also need to figure out how this actually works in my street query, which operates on exclusionary rules. This gets complicated because the lack of any toll:foot tag matches a != no check (which means 2,099 toll roads in Norway would get added to CityStrides).
Would using foot=permissive be an option to work around the issue with foot=no including every street that does not have a foot= value?