City-Specific Challenge Showing Progress Outside The City

I created a challenge for myself to run a particular city (in my case for the second time). When I view that challenge I see all of my activities I’ve done since creating that challenge even if they are in different cities. And when I look at the list of completed streets they are for all of my activities (ie other cities).

I would like, when creating a challenge that is limited to a specific city, that the activities, and the map of that challenge, to only show activities within that city border.

The LifeMap isn’t filtered by city due to that data being unavailable at the time of filtering. I don’t currently see a clear path forward in achieving this - I think I’d need to pre-calculate relevant city/street IDs to embed within the LifeMap data, which feels pretty ‘heavy’ both in processing time and storage space. I’m not saying “no” to this idea, but I do want to set expectations that it’s likely not coming soon.

Can you share a screen shot of an example of a street outside the city appearing in the list for your Ankeny Extra Credit Challenge? As an example, this is a Challenge I have set up locally for testing & all the city names show up as I’d expect:

Can you clarify what you’re seeing when you refer to “the activities”? I ask because Challenge pages do not currently list activities, so I’m unsure what you’re looking at.

See this screenshot showing nodes from the cities Des Moines and Johnston.

When I say other activities I mean by looking at the challenge map not an actual list of activities.

I expected to see only activities within the border of Ankeny.

Thanks!

I believe the issue is that back in May I made some adjustments so that Node Hunter would work properly in Challenge pages, but these changes actually conflicted with the street list.
I’m hoping to get the full fix out later this evening, but I do have a swamped schedule this weekend so it’s possible that I won’t get to it until late Sunday/Monday.

And just to reiterate the situation with the activity display on the LifeMap:
The LifeMap isn’t filtered by city due to that data being unavailable at the time of filtering. I don’t currently see a clear path forward in achieving this - I think I’d need to pre-calculate relevant city/street IDs to embed within the LifeMap data, which feels pretty ‘heavy’ both in processing time and storage space. I’m not saying “no” to this idea, but I do want to set expectations that it’s likely not coming soon.

This thread ended up being more of a #support thing than an #ideas thing. I’m going to move it over. If you want to add a “Limit displayed activities to those within the border for a city-based Challenge” to #ideas you’re welcome to!

Thank you, as always, for your efforts.

I’m not too concerned about the display. It was just an observation.