Is it at all possible that you had already signed into CityStrides separately via these two services?
I cannot reproduce the direct experience of clicking connect and being taken to a different CityStrides account. I can reproduce it by taking a longer path:
- log into CityStrides through serviceA
- log out of CityStrides
- log into CityStrides through serviceB
- log out of CityStrides & log back in through serviceA
- click the connect button for serviceB in the settings page
- this logs me into CityStrides as the second account (through serviceB)
I can merge your two accounts. Let me know if you’re OK with your Garmin-connected account merging into your Strava-connected account (the lower user ID, in case you’re into that). Oh, I’ll also cancel one of your subscriptions after the merge!
Thanks for reporting this.