[image] Missing/Broken Cities Tracker lots of stuff in England/Scotland needs closer review Source: Missing/Broken Cities Tracker - #4 by JamesChevalier I found this Google docs: Missing/Broken Cities Tracker - Google Sheets Most of the “cities” in Scotland aren’t cities. They’re just towns…

Completely agree. I looked at the the source you referenced and I really don’t follow the logic of why Scottish council areas are too big to be added - particularly when the streets contained within them are invisible to CS because the towns within them are deemed too tiny. How are the large, subu…

Feels like there is quite a bit of confusion about what is and isn’t included in Scotland. For example there are some Council Wards for Edinburgh / Clackmannanshire / Aberdeenshire which aren’t towns or cities by any normal understanding, but other places have nothing - e.g. Lanarkshire. At least ad…

[image] Michael Shanks: At least adding the 32 local authorities would be consistent My point exactly. Currently 75% of the area in Scotland have streets whose completion show zero progress in CS - see attached image [Scotland missing streets] Adding the 32 Council Areas ( Subdivisions of …

Totally agree - so how do we go about fixing this? They are all in the spreadsheet queue as far as I can see? @JamesChevalier any suggestions for what we can do to help?

There’s quite a bit covered in this comparatively short thread. I’ll start with an update on how I’m fixing things up based on feedback in this thread, and then I’ll try to cover each of the individual points. :heavy_check_mark: I’m removing everything that’s in CityStrides below admin level 6, or…

James, Thank you for the thorough response! Your 4-step plan makes sense. There very well may be some proper cities nested below admin level 6, but it sounds like those will be added back And I definitely misspoke when I send a straight-forward task! I did not mean these were exercises that wouldn…

Well, things are definitely different this morning! I’ve lost my previously completed ‘cities’ of Dunfermline and Carnoustie. Dunfermline was originally the only area in the county of Fife that was on the system and was then nested inside Fife. Now it is gone. Carnoustie makes a bit more sense as it…

I’m also a bit confused that missing nodes are appearing all over areas I’ve walked in Scotland but not in other parts of the world. [IMG_0921]

I’m having a similar issue – I’ve completed ~1100 streets in Glasgow which is wholly contained in West Central Scotland of which I’ve only completed 81 streets. Very odd.

[image] Jay Mackenzie: I’m having a similar issue – I’ve completed ~1100 streets in Glasgow which is wholly contained in West Central Scotland of which I’ve only completed 81 streets. Very odd I believe James is still in the midst of working through the processor-heavy tasks he listed in his …

The CityStrides Community

Missing cities in Scotland

Support

show post in topic

Home
Categories
Guidelines
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy

Powered by Discourse, best viewed with JavaScript enabled